Where did all the pro-Israel commentary come from?

30  2014-07-09 by [deleted]

A couple of weeks to a few months ago, all the usual suspects I had tagged as Pro-Israel in /r/worldnews would of course comment on anything to do with the conflict, and usually got told to fuck off. All of a sudden everyone is supporting Israel and saying that Hamas is evil for putting kids on the roofs (And downvoting anyone who asks why the fuck Israel blew said kids away)?

Did I miss something or has everyone turned anti-Palestine?

30 comments

Who needs a voice when all you need to do is click up or down.

I agree the mood has changed massively over the last 7 days.

Oddly enough I think that (in general) quieter subs are much more moderate than the defaults that get targeted by (?).

F'rinstance I actually lurk /r/israel lots (/r/palestine too) and in general - although things are obviously a bit tense now - zachof..., yamil... and rosinth.. etc. go down pretty badly there, moderates think they are dickheads too.

The vote manipulation on the big news subs does not correlate to anything except co-ordinated action, or an army of mindless redditors who really don't know fuck all but will click where the trends trend.

Don't know one way or the other but both prospects are kind of depressing.

*In the most serious single incident, seven Palestinians including two children were killed and about 25 wounded in an attack on a house in the Khan Younis area in south Gaza.

Residents said the house belonged to the family of a Hamas member and the casualties occurred when the property came under attack for the second time.

After the first strike people had gathered on the roof of the house as "human shields", hoping their presence would deter a second strike, the residents said. The Israeli military made no immediate comment about the incident.*

http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/jul/08/israel-pounds-gaza-against-hamas

Is Hamas sticking people on roofs, or are they standing in the way of fire to prevent further bombardment? And whether these "human shields" are defending their homes of their own accord, or by force, to dissuade the war crime of double-tapping a target, why is Israel striking their homes?

How is double-tapping a target a war crime? This would seem like common practice. Attempt to obliterate target. Satellite shows building still standing so you hit it again.

Not saying anything currently going on is right or wrong, but curious about how this would be a war crime.

I don't make the rules, homie. The UN has described 'double-tap' strikes as war crimes. You're hitting family, first responders and non-combatants.

It's even described as a terrorist tactic by the FBI.

Weird. Maybe within a particular timeframe. I know in WWII we bombed the same places over and over. Vietnam as well. But makes sense to not target first responders.

I know in WWII we bombed the same places over and over. Vietnam as well.

I think that's a good enough reasoning to stop using double tap practices...

*In the most serious single incident, seven Palestinians including two children were killed and about 25 wounded in an attack on a house in the Khan Younis area in south Gaza.

You do realize that Israel's enemies use this tactic quite often right? Fire a bunch of shit from a civilian area and act all surprised and outraged when Israel retaliates screaming "Oh israel is so evil, look what they did!"

they can't really fire shit from their non existent military areas eh? those are wiped out. maybe if your country was invaded, and your land taken, you would cowardly do nothing and stay peaceful?

maybe if your country was invaded, and your land taken

First of all its not their land...it is to be shared... Second, my country is invaded every day but you don't see people killing people over it because we aren't animals...

Israel has pushed for peace and splitting up the land but their enemies are barbaric and just want to kill all of them...

that's bs, nobody informed believes that.

Nobody "informed" believes what? That the land isn't solely the palestinians? Or that Israel has been pushing for peace?

If anyone here isn't informed its you...lol

Israel "has pushed for peace".

You should do stand up comedy!

You should get an education...

Oh I don't have one? Thanks for pointing that out to me random stranger on the Internet!

Oh I don't have one?

I mean, you made that clear.

Thanks

No problem.

You're a psychic too? Do your powers cross into the medium realm of things? Like, could you summon Caesar's ghost for me? Or maybe a better argument?

[deleted]

It was kind of lame man, there are far better arguments than looking at a picture of Tel Aviv and a picture of shittiest Detroit and saying Murica funded this!

Israel obviously has it's own industry, and economy.

e2a: man, sorry that was a bit of a shitty comment, and I did agree with the sentiment of the image - I just felt it was a little black and white.

I know it is quite dangerous to openly criticize Israel. Last time I did, out loud, these people went after me and digged up dirt about me. That was very very bad and cost me a lot of money and caused a major meltdown in my personal life.

https://www.facebook.com/groups/519883751373025/

But that doesn't mean we should stay afraid.

Last time I did, out loud, these people went after me and digged up dirt about me.

Bullshit. Stop lying please.

Edit: how does anyone read what he wrote and believe it? Don't be stupid guys.

She.

I should stop speaking garbage yes? I am talking garbage, garbage. Because there is all garbage across the internets.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hMBramnCg_s

mind control is the answer. there's a reason wilhelm reich's books were burned by the ton by US gov, he was right, 98% of humanity are psychologically diseased biological robots and war is one symptom. Young people are now acclimated to war, and a large amount of them fall for the same old fallacy of consensus. they still have not learned from nazi germany the real lesson which is that consensus of the ignorant is meaningless

consensus of the ignorant is meaningless

Tell that to those who believe in the man-made global warming scam.

Please stop saying this. You take away all credibility from yourself (and this sub) when you claim something that is overwhelmingly supported by hard, scientific data is just a large conspiracy. About 99% of scientists agree on the topic, so unless you're claiming that 99% of a very well-educated and critically thinking population are all wrong, you're clearly mistaken.

a very well-educated and critically thinking population

money and career paths motivate these people just like it does the wage slave factory workers.

instead of selling their souls for 50c ph pay-rises, they sell their souls for BMWs, tenured jobs, and academic grants and community fellowship.

if theres money involved, ethics and morals go out the window.

they wear nice clothes and smell nicer, thats the only difference.

What you said does apply to some people but "scientists" as a whole don't make a ton of money. Outside of doctors (and only certain specialties at that), dentists, etc. their average salaries aren't what you're thinking.

Even if we exclude the healthcare professions you're envisioning, a vast vast majority of non-medical doctors agree with my stance. I don't have a statistic that excludes "people who make a lot of money" but I'm pretty confident that most educated scientists agree with the current theory of climate change solely because that's where the evidence has led us.

It's the Hasbara.

Because people are better informed these days.

But not you.

[deleted]

Or it's just being gamed that way...

"Hama's must have forced these people to stay."

Bullshit. Have you forgotten how suicidal oppressed people can be? Women and children regularly volunteer for suicide bombing missions. In fact, women are many times more likely to use a suicide bombing as an assassination attempt than men, who blow themselves up less strategically.

The only reason Israel isn't suicide bombing Palestine is that they have way more options available to them, thanks to Western funding.

The human shields argument doesn't hold up when Israel appears happy to shoot and bomb human shields.

Last time I did, out loud, these people went after me and digged up dirt about me.

Bullshit. Stop lying please.

Edit: how does anyone read what he wrote and believe it? Don't be stupid guys.