/r/conspiracy false flag?
7 2014-09-25 by --_-_-_-_-_-_-_--
http://www.reddit.com/r/conspiracy/comments/2heen9/rconspiracy_was_an_inside_job/
Create a neo nazi problem. Use it to sensor sub!
7 2014-09-25 by --_-_-_-_-_-_-_--
http://www.reddit.com/r/conspiracy/comments/2heen9/rconspiracy_was_an_inside_job/
Create a neo nazi problem. Use it to sensor sub!
35 comments
6 alexdrac 2014-09-25
the term is honeypot
2 OB1_kenobi 2014-09-25
This reminds me of the recent goings on at 4chan.
A controversy gets started, then you get a flood of sjw mods coming in to solve "the problem". To my way of thinking, political correctness is just the modern term for censorship. And that's what sjw's are all about.
You could post pretty much anything you want when it comes to conspiracies. But if there's one area you want to be careful of, it's conspiracies based on "certain ethnic affiliations". It's the old tension between freedom of expression and hate speech.
3 --_-_-_-_-_-_-_-- 2014-09-25
On one hand you say
and then you say
1 fuckyoua 2014-09-25
No it's just when you're trying to open people's minds and you say "hey check out this website it's really cool they have a lot of interesting things on it". And you go to the site and the first thing that pops up is a big picture of fucking Hitler. That person is NOT going to open his/her mind. That person is going to close the browser and think "damn I thought this guy was cool but he's an ignorant racist who browses Hitler forums" and never talk to you again. You have to know that people see Hitler as bad. And any amount of trying to explain why you're showing Hitler documentaries isn't going to cut it with those people and frankly doesn't cut it with me.
This is the 2nd and hopefully the last time I'm unsubscribing from this sub. You guys get more racist day by day.
1 --_-_-_-_-_-_-_-- 2014-09-25
same applies for any topic on this sub.. people will come and see 911 or aliens or whatever else and think NOPE...
You may be offended by Hitler topics and lots of people are offended by other topics. You have a fucking brain and you can chose to ignore stuff. Otherwise if you start censoring everything then this sub dies. Honestly we dont need people like you in this sub!
1 fuckyoua 2014-09-25
Hey let's have a child molester documentary next! Those guys aren't so bad. Who care's who it offends? That will bring in and wake up lots of people! /s
I have my own sub. I care less about this racist sub.
/r/projectconspiracy
Join so I can ban you.
0 OB1_kenobi 2014-09-25
Yes, I'm a hypocrite. On the other hand I don't want to see this sub get taken over by sjw type mods.
1 strokethekitty 2014-09-25
Not many can admit to this, sadly.
3 OB1_kenobi 2014-09-25
Thanks for understanding. Here's my problem. Everybody still thinks the internet is some kind of wild west, anything goes free speech forum. It used to be, but things are changing.
If you're familiar with Marshall McLuhan, you'll know that saying about how "The medium is the message."
He was talking about television.... a medium where the viewer passively observes the content. So the message is passivity and acceptance.
What's the message for the internet? On first glance, it would appear to be activity and participation. You seek out the sites that interest you. Participate in discussions and even create and upload your own content. But there's another side to this that most people don't often consider.
All of this participation is by permission only. Let's use reddit itself as an example. Reddit is a business and, as such, has owners. These owners are going to make sure that their business is run in the way that is good for business. That's what forms the basis for their values. The owners will only hire admins that share these values (or at least put them into practice). This gets passed from the admins to the moderators.
So the message is that members of reddit only get to participate in reddit if they display conformity to the values of the owners/admins. Conformity to the values of the elite.
This might not be the case with every website right now, but it looks like that's the way things are going. If the medium is the message, the internet is not about freedom and individuality..... it's about conforming to the values of the elite.
Anyone who doesn't believe me is free to check out the rules section of the sidebar. Go ahead and make some comments that break the rules. Then see how long your free speech rights keep the mods from banning you.
1 strokethekitty 2014-09-25
Nicely said. I want to add a little bit, concerning free speech directly.
Most people dont understand that our right of free speech only applies to public spaces. Reddit, facebook, etc, is owned by folks. They are not public domain. Therefore, the owners have full ownership of the content within their domain. To limit their sovereignty upon their intellectual property would be limiting their rights as well.
For instance, if i invite you into my home, and then you start preaching to me about jesus, i have every right to ask (not force) you to stop. Should you refuse, i have every right to revoke that invitation and ban you from my domain. Same goes for these forums and social platforms on the net.
Also, the right of free speech only protects you from the government. It guarentees us that we can address our grievances, however trivial or factual, we might have, in an unsuppressed manner. The government cannot stop us (legally) from standing in a public space and preach that all of our leaders are reptilian overlords. They cant even ask us to stop.
However, another passerby is still allowed to tell you (not force you) to shut the fuck up. He has every right to call you a dumbass bitch for what you preach. That is his right to argue and say what he believes. A lot of folks get upset, invoke their right to free speech and stuff, when someone tries to tell them they are stupid or whatever, then they try to limit the free speech of the ones arguing them. Hypocrisy.
Look at the shot that westboro baptist gets for theor picketts. They are completely offensive, and i despise their ideology and methods of dissemination, but they have a right to express their beliefs, just like i have a right to express the fact that i believe they are delluded motherfuckers that have no respect for the people who died fighting for their right to say what they want.
However, they cannot be on the cemetary grounds during the funeral, as that is private domain. They can pickett on the streets and sidewalks like they do, legally, no matter their message.
So, coming full circle, it can be viewed as a good thing to allow censorship within private domains. To disallow it is to limit the rights of the domains owners.
As for r/conspiracy, i am greatful that, for the most part, censorship is not rampant and we get to discuss, in full detail sometimes, our beliefs, speculations, and theories about the most controversial topics. However, should reddit decide that we can no longer talk or discuss or analyze or even acknowledge holocaust revisionism, they have every right to do so. Its their platform.
Im just glad they havent gone that far (yet.)
1 Golisten2LennyWhite 2014-09-25
Thanks I needed that. So much bullshit these days.
3 SquareHimself 2014-09-25
Either nothing gets censored or everything will. If the jews did it, they might've did it. It's a plausible side to the story. I personally tend to skip over it for better meat, but there are infinite possibilities and you can't let political correctness get in the way.
1 orrery 2014-09-25
People are interested in WW2, posting a Hitler side image will attract more people for the simple reason that people find all things WW2 interesting.
I was not alive during WW2 and personally have mixed feelings on the topic, but no one is going to be driven away by a WW2 documentary except for maybe a WW2 vet who doesn't like thinking about, or some crying little bitch. People spent countless hours in their high school and college history and social studies classes discussing various points of views -- I'm pretty sure people can handle it.
-2 spasticbadger 2014-09-25
Also possible we, the users, need to make sure the mod who decided this is removed and not instead content and users censored.
5 Flytape 2014-09-25
We won't be removing any mods! Are you seriously suggesting that a mod be removed because they posted the documentary that was most voted on by the community?
Nope nope nope. Not going to happen.
2 PresidentRoguebomber 2014-09-25
You can't guarantee the organic nature of the votes though. That's a cop out.
1 Flytape 2014-09-25
A cop out would be removing it because we are scared of the flak.
2 PresidentRoguebomber 2014-09-25
You can't guarantee the organic nature of the votes though. - The statement you chose not to speak toward.
How many sockpuppets do you run?
0 Flytape 2014-09-25
No I can't guarantee the organic nature of the vote.
Nobody can! What difference does that make here?
I don't sock puppet.
2 PresidentRoguebomber 2014-09-25
The same difference it would make if SRS was posting misogynist materials here too bitch about in their own sub.
The same difference as the FBI bombing innocents and blaming adversaries.
The same difference as Tim Wise talking about white privilege while misrepresenting himself as a white person.
The voting system here and all over reddit is dysfunctional and inorganic. That means it is not a sound basis for determining the wants, desires and majority opinion of the groups it represents.
You know all this shit already, playing stupid is evidence of complicity. You're hiding behind a 'majority opinion' that cannot be determined to authentic.
0 Flytape 2014-09-25
So what? Err on the side of censorship?
2 PresidentRoguebomber 2014-09-25
Removing it from the sticky and from the sidebar wouldn't be censorship. The greater body of messaging here is at risk, if it isn't already DOA.
0 Flytape 2014-09-25
DoA? Our traffic is off the charts today.
Get over it.
2 PresidentRoguebomber 2014-09-25
Traffic isn't messaging. They're rubberneckers here to see the guts on the asphalt. I know you aren't stupid or naive, stop acting like it.
Would be nice if you could open those traffic statistics up the rest of us though.
0 spasticbadger 2014-09-25
I did not realise this is voted upon by the community, I was under the impression that documentaries were suggested and then the mods picked the most popular one. Either way this new doc should not be plastered on the front of our sub, it gives the wrong impression.
5 Flytape 2014-09-25
Okay so what are we allowed to post since we apparently have arbitrary limits on speech?
1 spasticbadger 2014-09-25
I'm still unclear on how the docs are chosen?
I myself cannot say which ones we can and cannot have, I am just one guy. However I love this community and it's related content and do not want it to be any more compromised. By allowing things like this to be stickied on our sub gives off the wrong impression and opens us up to more criticism and more importantly debate on whether r/conspiracy has gone to far and whether it's time for some big shot to step in and delete it. I get the impression they are just waiting for something like this to be used as an excuse. As a post it's fine, it can be voted upon and therefore it's importance decided in the sub by the users, having it stickied is too far in my opinion.
2 Flytape 2014-09-25
If you love this community then you will never again ask that something be removed or censored because it is offensive.
0 --_-_-_-_-_-_-_-- 2014-09-25
My point exactly. Anyone baiting to remove or sensor this sub has to be treated with suspicion!
0 spasticbadger 2014-09-25
I personally don't find it offensive, other people will though. Do you understand where I am coming from?
1 strokethekitty 2014-09-25
Not that i condone the holocaust revisionism thing, but didnt people find it offensive when some dude said the world was spherical, not flat?
Just because something offends other people doesnt mean it should be censored. I didnt watch this documentary, but ive done some resesrch. Imo, some arguments are certainly valid. But a lot of people take it too far and use it to support their bigotry and hatred of others. That is wrong.
Asking questions is not.
No matter how much it offends others, both sides of each story must be analyzed, lest we yield to bias and vacate our sovereignty to logical deducement ourselves...
0 Flytape 2014-09-25
Yes but do you understand that we get complaints about every single post in this sub? Everyone is offended by something. So if we limit ourselves based upon "someone might be offended by this guys" then we may as well make the sub private, ban everyone and turn the lights out for good.
1 spasticbadger 2014-09-25
I understand, wasn't aware of complaints of that magnitude though.
0 --_-_-_-_-_-_-_-- 2014-09-25
Well lets see how this plays out. Im guessing more censorship!
-3 AutoModerator 2014-09-25
While not required, you are requested to use the NP domain of reddit when crossposting. This helps to protect both your account, and the accounts of other users, from administrative shadowbans. The NP domain can be accessed by prefacing your reddit link with np.reddit.com.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
0 OB1_kenobi 2014-09-25
Yes, I'm a hypocrite. On the other hand I don't want to see this sub get taken over by sjw type mods.
1 fuckyoua 2014-09-25
No it's just when you're trying to open people's minds and you say "hey check out this website it's really cool they have a lot of interesting things on it". And you go to the site and the first thing that pops up is a big picture of fucking Hitler. That person is NOT going to open his/her mind. That person is going to close the browser and think "damn I thought this guy was cool but he's an ignorant racist who browses Hitler forums" and never talk to you again. You have to know that people see Hitler as bad. And any amount of trying to explain why you're showing Hitler documentaries isn't going to cut it with those people and frankly doesn't cut it with me.
This is the 2nd and hopefully the last time I'm unsubscribing from this sub. You guys get more racist day by day.