Gravity just doesn't make sense in space

0  2017-07-02 by [deleted]

[deleted]

43 comments

r/science

That's the last place you want to look.

Exactly, because /r/askscience is the correct subreddit.

That's the last place you want to look.

Fine, here is the sources that are only acceptable here

youtube.com, 4chan.org, twitter.com

Nice try ;)

Friction, bungee cords, space staples, and the fact that the sun is made of light as a wave, not a particle, so it has no mass.

Not made of light, light is a by-product of fusion

I think part of the reason they don't get sucked back to earth is because they are in orbit... Traveling at a high rate of speed around the earth which essentially pushes them back out.

Regarding earth and sun, I have always wondered this. You could point again to orbit, but I have always wondered if there are other forces that we have yet to discover, like a force that works opposite of gravity.

For some reason the idea of us rotating around the sun without closing in on it has always been strange to me. I have this silly idea in my head that maybe it's like a slow toilet flush and maybe billions of years ago a planet such as mercury was our distance from the sun, and some day mars will be in the sweet spot we now enjoy.

Iss is fake

That's what I think

If you go to somewhere without too much light polution you can see it with the naked eye goy

You can literally see it with the naked eye.

spotthestation.nasa.gov

Tesla had some very interesting views about gravity.

Yes? Go on! Any recommended reading?

Give me a little bit of time to find it. I just drank some killer beer and I need some time to find it. Right now, I am very concerned about Trump getting the Gentiles to die killing Iranians for Israel. You do know that Jews want Gentiles to die killing Persians, don't you? I'm a Jew who knows this shit.

All I know is those Jews aren't the real Jews imho

I dare you to walk up to some yamaka wearing Jew and say "you ain't a real Jew!". Let's see what happens.

Why is it that astronauts would feel weightless when they are still feeling 90% of earths gravitational effect?

The earth is under an atmospheric pressure, and since humans are 90% water, and water is denser than air, we are bound to the earth by gravity and density. In space where there is a lack of atmosphere, humans will behave much like water.

Why would they float around weightlessly on the space station but be able to hop up and down on the moon?

The moon has gravity?

The space between the moon and earth is not just some zero gravity zone if in fact it is earth's gravity that is holding the moon in orbit.

The earth isn't holding the moon in orbit, in fact the moon is straying further and further away from the earth.

isn't our moon slowly getting closer to us? Common sense would seem to dictate that if a force is strong enough to attract two bodies, these bodies would inevitably collide.

The solar system is a balancing act, and the larger planets in our outer solar system plays a hug role in maintaining perpetual orbit around our sun.

Disclaimer: I'm not an astro physicist and I don't have a fucking clue what I'm talking about.

I don't have a fucking clue what I'm talking about.

I hate to be mean, but clearly.

why is it that astronauts would feel weightless when they are still feeling 90% of earths gravitational effect

Because they aren't standing still up there, they're moving at many kilometers per second to have an orbit, while in orbit, you are countering earth's gravity with angular momentum

To even further simplify why they feel no effect of gravity...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reduced-gravity_aircraft <- Its the same principle.

Astronauts are falling at a rate that is equal to the gravitational pull of the earth.

Gravity is the weakest of the natural forces and can be overcome simply with a child holding a magnet over a paper clip.

Others have said it, but the key concept around an orbit is basically falling and missing. If I am a million miles from earth and throw a ball straight at earth, it will fall towards earth with the speed of my throw plus gravity.

If I throw it away from earth, it will travel away from earth with the speed of my throw minus gravity. If the pull of gravity is greater than the force of my throw, it will eventually stop and then fall to earth.

Now, if I throw it perpendicular to the line between me and earth it will start traveling perpendicular then bend towards earth due to gravity.

If I throw with a light force, gravity will pull the ball down towards earth.

If I throw with a super strong force, it would speed away from earth and only bend towards earth slightly before gravity became so week it had no effect.

Right in between those, there is a speed I can throw the ball where it can't quite speed away from earth, but is still being pulled towards earth by gravity. So it moves perpendicular a little way (my force), moves down a little way (gravity), moves perpendicularly, moves down, etc., etc.

The end result is that the ball is always falling towards earth but never hitting it - an orbit.

This post betrays a very basic misunderstanding of physics. All observable on small and larger scales. "they" didn't make up physics, it's all there an it all makes sense. Now, as to whether we live in a simulation, the jury is out 🙃

jesus christ! please stop these stupid fucking posts on gravity.

it doesn't matter how many times you have it explained to you... you purposely act dumb and then post the same shit again.

what in the actual fuck is your problem?

What is your problem? If you don't like my post how about you just skim past it? What is the need to troll me? Is your life that boring?

you keep posting the same thing. why not read the answers you have already been given? you are trolling - not me.

I made two different posts. One about gravity in space and one about density vs gravity. They may be related, but they are in no way the same posts. Get a life and go get on someone else's thread.

get a brain and stop posting this idiocy.

What are you the Reddit police lol

no... the members of this sub are. that's why your posts are zero lol.

Is must be fun being a troll 24/7. If you'd just shed the weight I'm sure you could make friends in real life too 😂

that's trolltastic. keep it up! i'll be seeing you gravity denier ;)

Removed. Rule 10.

Removed. Rule 10.

The problem is your questions are, honestly, stupid questions based on ignorance that could be answered by starting with wikipedia.

Gravity is definitely not a conspiracy.

Gravity is determined by mass. The more mass (the amount of matter contained within an object...not its size) an object has the more gravity it "generates".

Density does not determine the amount of gravity. Density determines the size of the object. Mass determines gravity.

But what do I know. I'm a plumber who watches too much Discovery channel and Science Channel.

Based on the assumptions we know the masses of the planets.

But density does cause an object to sink rather than float in a fluid. Therefore an objects relative density does determine whether it would float, sink, or rise. Look at helium. If you throw a helium filled balloon into the air it will rise and rise until it meets equilibrium. There it will stay until enough helium is gone that the balloon becomes more dense and then falls back to earth. Is this gravity at work or bouyancy? I think the answer to this is obvious. So then, why is it hard to believe that a ball thrown up in the air falls back down to earth because of its higher density than the air? Try this over water and you will find that the ball falls back down until it is met with a fluid that is more dense, water, at which point it floats. Try the same with a rock and it will sink into the water until it is met with a solid. Try it with an egg over the ocean and it will sink until it is at equal density with the water.

Don't let him get you down. WW3 will be Flat Earth = NASA/SATAN GRAND DECEPTION. I give it 2 years.

These people are like arguing with a child. They state things, you disprove them, they ignore this and then personally attack you. It's just really entertaining.

yes another brilliant genie who will debunk 3000 years of science, because he doesn't understand it

jesus christ people pick up a book or something

I mean the space station itself has to keep constantly propell itself in order to not fall back into the earth.

it does, NEXT?

Escape velocity. The farther you are away from a planet or moon, the less energy you need to escape it's gravity. Gravity is all about the uneven distribution of mass in space/time. In areas where the mass is distributed low like the space between Earth and the Moon, there will be little to no gravity.

Escape velocity. The moon is slowly with each rotation moving away from the Earth. Same with the Sun.

The space station does not have enough mass and speed to propell away. The moon's rotation around the earth is what likely causes the slow moving away from Earth. The space station simply is not rotating earth fast enough to be able to stay without using propulsion.

There are more than one different forces acting on you at all times and their pull never correlates linearly to distance. You should already have some intuition to this by playing with magnets. They can pull really hard when up close but at only a few cm away they don't seem to be pulling at all even though they technically are.

combine this with swinging a bucket full of water, when everything is swinging and orbiting it wants to fly away and does unless something pulls on it(or restricts in another manner).

Not made of light, light is a by-product of fusion